Ripping
it up in a Thunderbird at 1.46 ghz...
All the way live with
AMD's latest weapon the Athlon Thunderbird
1.33ghz 266 axia clocked to 1.46ghz 11x133mhz
This will be a very straightforward article since I'm
certainly not an electrical engineer and I don't like acting like one. I'm a
gamer...more specifically I am mainly interested in games that many people
say are CPU bound. These include Flight simulations, racing sims and other
related games. Turns out that these are exactly the types of games that
benefit the most from getting a massively fast CPU like the Athlon
Thunderbird 1.33ghz 266mhz and over clocking it. So that's exactly what I did
all the way to 1.46ghz!. And since everyone is full of questions of whether
this upgrade is worth it I figured to take some benchmarks from a couple few
games and compare this machine to my old P-III 743mhz. Before we start with
the benchmarks lets go over a few things with a little bit of how-to so that
someone with clever hands can do this for themselves.
With my old machine I had a couple of pieces that I felt
could make the transition. One my Voodoo 5 card, while it probably is
holding this CPU up a bit I just cannot live without the awesome FSAA. That
is just such a terrific feature that this card will remain in my puter till
someone comes out with better FSAA. In addition I had 256mb of HSDRAM
from Mushkin that seemed to be doing fine and certainly would make a
fine addition to the mix. I had purchased that ram with the belief that I
could always overclock the bus easier than upping the multiplier. It turned
out that it was actually easier on my machine to up the multiplier since
that had little affect on the ancillary pieces in my puter. For instance my
V5 was not at all happy about running at 153mhz though I could play games
and benchmark happily at that bus speed. I felt it wasn't stable since at
boot up the Win98 screen was corrupted. Also my hardrives were not very
happy either. So in the end I just upped the multiplier which sort of meant
that I wasted money on HSDRAM since any decent 133mhz ram would have
sufficed. Oh well live and learn...at least I had the option and when
overclocking, options are good. My Enlight 300watt power supply and hardrives
all met the needs of my planned upgrade so off I went to Paragoncomp.com
to order my CPU. TC Computers had my choice for motherboards in stock and so
off went an order for the latest KK-266
Iwill.
I had chosen to stay with a regular SDRAM motherboard spec
since all the tests I had seen had both the SDRAM and DDR motherboards very
close. Having 256mb of sdram sealed the deal as it wasn't very likely that
"SHE WHO MUST BE OBEYED" would agree to me buying more ram.
Both parts came in on the same day and there I was staring
at my new stuff wondering whether I had made all the right choices. First
off I pulled my Alpha 6035 Cooler purchased from Plycon.com
off of my P-III and removed the ASUS motherboard from my Enlight case. The Iwill
KK-266 went right into the case with not much fuss at all. The package
and parts included with the Iwill were very well done and nothing was
missing that would make it difficult.
After hooking it all up and installing all of my hardware I
anxiously booted up. A non event is the best way to describe the ease at
which I had that computer up and running. Within 10minutes of booting up
without touching the voltage I had it up to its current 1.46ghz albeit by
using 153 bus speed. (I was still convinced that I couldn't run the
multiplier up to 11). To say that I was amazed at the new speed would be an
understatement. As I said earlier I ended up using the multiplier to
overclock just so that the rest of my puter wouldn't puke. The cpu and
memory didn't seem to mind one way or the other. So I ramped it up to a
11x133mhz and ended up with 1.46 at stock voltage. (more on voltage problems
later)
Benchmarks.....assume that everything is maxed out in
regards graphical splendor and cpu load. Also rest assured that I made sure
that the tests were run consistently from CPU to CPU.
| CPU |
Intel Pentium 3 Coppermine 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46ghz |
| Mobo |
Asus P3V4X |
Iwill KK-266 |
| RAM |
Mushkin HSDRAM 256mb |
| Video |
3dfx Voodoo 5 using 3dfx Beta 1.04.1 Drivers and Win
98se |
| OS |
Windows 98 Se and Direct X 8.0a |
| FALCON 4
using my benchmark
mission
|
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 640x480 x4 FSAA 16bit |
22.1 |
46.6 |
| 1024x768 x4 FSAA 16bit |
17.1 |
28.1 |
| 1024x768 x2 FSAA 16bit |
19.0 |
38.0 |
This
is exactly the type of speed up I was hoping for. I tend to play in 16bit
and with x2 FSAA and to see that type of improvements in the 1024x768 x2
FSAA was gratifying.
| B-17II by
Hasbro |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 1024x768 x0 FSAA 16bit |
34 |
53 |
| 1024x768 x2 FSAA 16bit |
25 |
32 |
| 1024x768 x4 FSAA 16bit |
15 |
17 |
Sure wish
that V5 had more fill rate. And yet the speed up in the resolution and FSAA
setting I use (1024x2FSAA) are enough to be impressed by.
| Janes
F/A-18 |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 640x480 x4 FSAA 16bit |
17 |
29 |
| 1024x768 x4 FSAA 16bit |
15 |
25 |
| 1024x768 x2 FSAA 16bit |
17 |
31 |
| 1024X768 X0 FSAA 16bit |
18 |
32 |
Obviously this was gratifying all the way around.
| Flanker
2.5 16bit |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 640x480 x4 FSAA |
15 |
26 |
| 1024x768 x4 FSAA |
13 |
26 |
| 1024x768 x2 FSAA |
13 |
26 |
| 1024x768 x0 FSAA |
13 |
26 |
Wow
I guess Flanker really likes CPU's...<G> No doubt these scores would
have been even higher with a Nvidia Geforce but the lack of quality FSAA
really hurts it for me.
| Operation
Flashpoint |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 1024x768 x0 FSAA 16bit |
23 |
36 |
| 1024x768 x2 FSAA 16bit |
23 |
36 |
| 1600x1200 x0 FSAA 16bit |
16 |
23 |
| 1600x1200 x2 FSAA 16bit |
10 |
16 |
This
is gonna be such an intense game that I pretty much decided to upgrade
because of this game.
| Nascar
4 |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 640x480 x2 FSAA 16bit |
42 |
82 |
| 1024x768 x0 FSAA 16bit |
40 |
80 |
| 1024X768 x2 FSAA 16bit |
40 |
59 |
| 1024x768 x4 FSAA 16bit |
30 |
30 |
| 1600x1200 x0 FSAA 16bit |
38 |
46 |
| 1600x1200 x2 FSAA 16bit |
27 |
28 |
Very
nice improvement at 1024x768 x0...wish I had more fill rate for the rest. Nvidia
get off your ass and make a card with great FSAA!
| Mechwarrior
4 |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 640x480 x0 FSAA 16bit |
70 |
117 |
| 1024x768 x0 FSAA 16bit |
70 |
113 |
| 1600x1200 x0 FSAA 16bit |
57 |
62 |
| 640x480 x2 FSAA 16bit |
70 |
117 |
| 1024x768 x2 FSAA 16bit |
70 |
100 |
| 1600x1200 x2 FSAA 16bit |
41 |
41 |
Boy
do I wish I had the time to get into this game.
| Combat
Flight Simulator 2 |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 640x480 x0 FSAA 16bit |
37 |
79 |
| 1024x768 x0 FSAA 16bit |
31 |
54 |
| 1600x1200 x0 FSAA 16bit |
23 |
33 |
| 640x480 x2 FSAA 16bit |
37 |
79 |
| 1024x768 x2 FSAA 16bit |
30 |
59 |
| 1600x1200 x2 FSAA 16bit |
26 |
26 |
| 640x480 x4 FSAA 16bit |
36 |
65 |
| 1024x768 x4 FSAA 16bit |
29 |
30 |
| 1024x768 x0 32bit |
31 |
51 |
| 1024x768 x2 32bit |
31 |
42 |
Its
spectacular to see this game at 1024 x2 FSAA running at 59 frames a second.
With a smoooothness....!!!!
| Grand
Prix Legends Full Grid Monoco starting 19th. |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| 1024x768 x4 FSAA 16bit |
16.5 |
29.5 |
This
is a big one for me and probably I should have done more benchmarks. Got
lazy hehe....Anyways x4 FSAA is finally playable and worth every frame. Its
playable since as soon at the grid leaves the framerate jumps up to the
limited 36 frames a second.
| 3D
Mark 2000 all tests run at 1024x768 x0 FSAA 16bit |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
| Average FPS |
Average FPS |
| Helicopter Low Detail |
82 |
112.6 |
| Helicopter Medium Detail |
52 |
77.6 |
| Helicopter High Detail |
21 |
32.2 |
| Adventure Low Detail |
95 |
109.9 |
| Adventure Med Detail |
48 |
84.7 |
| Adventure High Detail |
27.5 |
53.5 |
| 3DMark
2001 |
Intel P-III 743mhz |
Athlon Thunderbird 1.46 |
Average FPS 32bit
640x480 x2 FSAA |
Average FPS 32bit
640x480 x2 FSAA |
| Car Chase low detail |
21 |
42.1 |
| Car Chase High Detail |
6.9 |
16.1 |
| Dragothic Low Detail |
20.2 |
40.6 |
| Dragothic High Detail |
6.7 |
13.8 |
| Lobby Low Detail |
42.4 |
65.5 |
| Lobby High Detail |
18.9 |
32.5 |
Overall
this was very easy and painless. For just over 418.00 Dollars US including
shipping I dramatically upped the speed in all the games I play at the
resolutions and FSAA settings I use. There
was
only one serious problem that I encountered when using my new equipement.
The
problem is the bug in the Iwill bios that causes the Voltage to either be
displayed incorrectly or to actually be set incorrectly. For instance
currently I have my vCore voltage set to 1.70 but in the PC health display
in the Bios its listed running at 1.77. My 3.3 voltage is also running out
of spec at 3.9 volts. If this is merely an incorrect display and the voltage
is set correctly then no worries. But if it is indeed set at 1.77 then that
is indeed a problem from a heat standpoint. The way I have gotten around
this problem is to set the bios to a lower than standard voltage. Doing this
leads me to believe that it is indeed an actual incorrect setting since when
I do set it to the lower voltage my CPU temp lowers to the range thats
normal for the Athlon Thunderbird.
Highly
recommend this upgrade.
Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand
|